Skip to Content
CityRealty Logo
Henderson House via Corcoran Henderson House via Corcoran
You're not imagining it - Thanksgiving is very early this year, and we'll be gathering around the table for turkey by this time next week. Between the feasts most people have planned and the length of the guest lists, it's no wonder the holiday requires a large dining table...the likes of which are not thought likely to fit in a typical New York apartment. It doesn't help that in most modern construction, open floor plans have all but decimated the dining room. So where does that leave New Yorkers - going out to eat or angling for an invitation to someone's house?

Not necessarily. By perusing prewar homes on the Upper West Side, Upper East Side, and in between, we were able to find quintessentially New York apartments with formal dining rooms large enough to host Thanksgiving dinner. Some of these buildings date back to the early 20th century, but the kitchens have been renovated with high-end appliances and enough room to painlessly cook a feast, too. And in something else to give thanks for, all of the following apartments are priced under $5 million.

In this article:

The Sherwood, 325 Riverside Drive
The Sherwood, 325 Riverside Drive Riverside Dr./West End Ave.
Carnegie House, 100 West 57th Street
Carnegie House, 100 West 57th Street Midtown West
901 Lexington Avenue
901 Lexington Avenue Lenox Hill
1133 Park Avenue
1133 Park Avenue Carnegie Hill
Henderson House, 535 East 86th Street
Henderson House, 535 East 86th Street Yorkville
 
 
 
 
900-Fifth-Avenue
Enlarge Image
900-Fifth-Avenue
Enlarge Image
900-Fifth-Avenue
Enlarge Image
900-Fifth-Avenue
Enlarge Image
900-Fifth-Avenue
Enlarge Image
900-Fifth-Avenue
Enlarge Image
Located in a full-service cooperative in the Upper East Side Historic District, this beautiful apartment has direct Central Park views from the living room, library, and master bedroom. A gracious 16' gallery with marble floors leads to the formal dining room. Directly next to it, the windowed gourmet kitchen is equipped with custom cabinetry and top-of-the-line appliances. See full details here.

 
 
 
 
325-Riverside-Drive
Enlarge Image
325-Riverside-Drive
Enlarge Image
325-Riverside-Drive
Enlarge Image
325-Riverside-Drive
Enlarge Image
325-Riverside-Drive
Enlarge Image
325-Riverside-Drive
Enlarge Image
In this sprawling Upper West Side co-op, the formal dining room has open north and partial river views, as does the windowed eat-in kitchen. The master suite has its own wing, and the three other bedrooms are in a separate wing away from the entertaining areas. Additional features include original prewar details, living room with garden views, hardwood floors, and in-unit washer/dryer. See full details here.

 
 
 
 
60-East-End-Avenue
Enlarge Image
60-East-End-Avenue
Enlarge Image
60-East-End-Avenue
Enlarge Image
60-East-End-Avenue
Enlarge Image
60-East-End-Avenue
Enlarge Image
High-floor Yorkville home offers unobstructed views of the East River, the city skyline, and the three bridges. The sprawling living room faces east, and a formal dining room and recently renovated kitchen look out on views to the west. All bedrooms have well-proportioned layouts, excellent closet space, and en suite baths.See full details here.

 
 
 
 
15-West-67th-Street
Enlarge Image
15-West-67th-Street
Enlarge Image
15-West-67th-Street
Enlarge Image
15-West-67th-Street
Enlarge Image
15-West-67th-Street
Enlarge Image
Dramatic apartment in the West 67th Street Artists' Colony Historic District has the feel of a townhouse with its 11' ceilings, pine flooring, grand-scale rooms, and trompe l'oeil decor. The expansive living room and equally large formal dining room are filled with amazing natural light from towering conservatory windows. Chef's kitchen offers cherry cabinetry, state-of-the-art appliances, and granite countertops. See full details here.

 
 
 
 
535-East-86th-Street
Enlarge Image
535-East-86th-Street
Enlarge Image
535-East-86th-Street
Enlarge Image
535-East-86th-Street
Enlarge Image
535-East-86th-Street
Enlarge Image
535-East-86th-Street
Enlarge Image
Spacious Yorkville penthouse is filled with incredible light and East River views. Features include a private terrace, soaring ceilings, hand-painted crown molding, gold filigree doors, and Grecian columns. The formal dining room is large enough to host Thanksgiving dinner, and the kitchen has enough room for a table for at least four. See full details here.
Would you like to tour any of these properties?
Just complete the info below.
  1. Select which properties are of interest to you:

Or call us at (212) 755-5544

 
 
 
 
137-East-15th-Street
Enlarge Image
137-East-15th-Street
Enlarge Image
137-East-15th-Street
Enlarge Image
137-East-15th-Street
Enlarge Image
137-East-15th-Street
Enlarge Image
137-East-15th-Street
Enlarge Image
A few blocks from Union Square, this beautiful duplex penthouse in a historic townhouse offers soaring ceilings, a private roof deck, Old World charm, and a working fireplace with custom bookshelves on either side. The formal dining room boasts exposed brick walls and three oversized windows that fill it with incredible natural light. Up the spiral staircase, the master suite has excellent closet space, a full bath, and wide plank floors. See full details here.

 
 
 
 
100-West-57th-Street
Enlarge Image
100-West-57th-Street
Enlarge Image
100-West-57th-Street
Enlarge Image
100-West-57th-Street
Enlarge Image
100-West-57th-Street
Enlarge Image
100-West-57th-Street
Enlarge Image
No detail was overlooked in the recent renovation of this centrally located Midtown home. A spacious living room features custom lighting and beautiful city views. The modern kitchen is outfitted with custom cabinetry and Miele appliances, and flows seamlessly into the formal dining room for excellent entertaining. See full details here.

 
 
 
 
1133-Park-Avenue
Enlarge Image
1133-Park-Avenue
Enlarge Image
1133-Park-Avenue
Enlarge Image
1133-Park-Avenue
Enlarge Image
1133-Park-Avenue
Enlarge Image
Gracious prewar residence in the heart of Carnegie Hill offers high beamed ceilings, hardwood floors, moldings, and excellent flow for entertaining. Directly off the formal dining room is a renovated windowed kitchen with wood cabinetry and top-of-the-line appliances. The bedrooms are located in their own wing for privacy, and the staff room has been enlarged enough to be a full fourth bedroom. See full details here.

 
 
 
 
360-Riverside-Drive
Enlarge Image
360-Riverside-Drive
Enlarge Image
360-Riverside-Drive
Enlarge Image
360-Riverside-Drive
Enlarge Image
360-Riverside-Drive
Enlarge Image
360-Riverside-Drive
Enlarge Image
Corner residence in an architecturally significant cooperative offers exposure in all directions, wonderful natural light, spacious rooms, and easy access to Riverside Park and prime Upper West Side dining and transportation. The dining room and secondary bedroom boast custom-made, floor-to-ceiling cherry bookcases. All bedrooms are oversized, and all baths are windowed. See full details here.

 
 
 
 
901-Lexington-Avenue
Enlarge Image
901-Lexington-Avenue
Enlarge Image
901-Lexington-Avenue
Enlarge Image
901-Lexington-Avenue
Enlarge Image
901-Lexington-Avenue
Enlarge Image
901-Lexington-Avenue
Enlarge Image
Sun-flooded Lenox Hill co-op features open skyline views, oversized windows, high ceilings, and original moldings and floors. The double parlor has a wood-burning fireplace and a bookcase that slides aside to reveal a full bath. The formal dining room faces south and is filled with sunny exposures. See full details here.
Enjoyed this Article? Like CityRealty on Facebook and follow @CityRealty on Instagram. You can also tweet us at @CityRealtyNY.
Would you like to tour any of these properties?
Just complete the info below.
  1. Select which properties are of interest to you:

Or call us at (212) 755-5544
Would you like to tour any of these properties?
Content Specialist Michelle Mazzarella Michelle is a contributing writer and editor for real estate news in New York City