Skip to Content
CityRealty Logo
Upper East Side

NYC's spookiest buildings that you'd totally live in anyway

The Octago, The Dakota, and 55 Central Park West The Octago, The Dakota, and 55 Central Park West
Many horror movies involve an individual or family unwittingly moving into a haunted house and living in terror, but such scenarios are highly unlikely to play out in New York. State law requires that if a seller has previously made claims about a property having supernatural activity (e.g., been part of a ghost tour or applied to be on a paranormal television show), they are obligated to inform buyers.
If a seller only knows that someone had previously died in the home or has suspicions of ghostly activity, they do not have to disclose this information, which could set some up for possible paranormal activity. That being said, most horror movies don’t take New Yorkers’ intrepidity into account. They know that the city’s history contains scary, even grisly stories, and that some of them are associated with the city’s most prestigious addresses. What’s more, it would appear that some embrace the idea of a building where terrifying things have happened either onscreen or in real life. A closer look at the city’s most famous residential buildings with spooky reputations revealed a small handful of public availabilities.

In this article:

The Spencer Condominium, 1 East 62nd Street
The Spencer Condominium, 1 East 62nd Street Park/Fifth Ave. to 79th St.
455 Central Park West
455 Central Park West Central Park West
55 Central Park West
55 Central Park West Central Park West
The Dakota, 1 West 72nd Street
The Dakota, 1 West 72nd Street Central Park West
267 West 11th Street
267 West 11th Street West Village

Architect: Henry J. Hardenbergh | Built in 1882
Neighborhood: Central Park West
93 Units | 10 Floors

The-Dakota-Central-Park03 The Dakota (Douglas Elliman)
The Dakota is perhaps the city's most legendary apartment building, and one might think that between Rosemary's Baby (where it was used for exterior shots of the fictional Bramford), John Lennon's murder, and a host of reported ghost sightings throughout the years, this massive, fortress-like co-op building with apartments as big as its reputation would scare people off. But it's still one of the most coveted residences in the city.

The Dakota, #84 (Douglas Elliman Real Estate)

Architect: Charles Coolidge Haight | Built in 1887
Neighborhood: Central Park West
99 Units | 25 Floors

455-Central Park West-03 455 Central Park West (Compass)
Among the neighborhood's surrounding townhouses and historic co-op buildings, the stunning architectural anomaly that is the "castle" at 455 Central Park West has a dark medical history as New York’s first cancer hospital. Built in 1887, when cancer treatment was somewhat of an oxymoron, the castle had a crematorium and a smokestack at the back that was often in use. The hospital closed in 1955, but it wasn't until a redevelopment plan took off in 2000 that it welcomed more fortunate residents at a luxury condo development.

455 Central Park West, #PH2/3 (Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices New York Properties)

Architect: Schwartz & Gross | Built in 1930
Neighborhood: Central Park West
109 Units | 20 Floors

55-Central-Park-West-03 A spookier 55 Central Park West shown in 1984 movie Ghostbusters
55 Central Park West is a prewar cooperative made famous in the 1984 film Ghostbusters. Its Gothic-like Art Deco stylings made the perfect fit (in addition to some CGI which increased its height and scare factor) to play the central haunted high-rise in the film. The building is sometimes colloquially known as Spook Central or the Shandor Building, the fictional names it's given in the film. Quite lovely in person, the landmarked building was designed by the architectural firm Schwartz & Gross and finished in 1929. Its exterior brickwork transitions from a dark tone to a more yellow tone thought to make it seem as if the sun were always shining on the building. Not spooky at all.
55 Central Park West, Upper West Side luxury cooperative 55 Central Park West as it appears off-screen (Brown Harris Stevens)

55 Central Park West, #7BCD (Brown Harris Stevens Residential Sales LLC)

Architect: Horace Trumbauer | Built in 1904
Neighborhood: Upper East Side Gold Coast
12 Condos | 6 Floors

1-East-62nd-Street-01 The Spencer Condominium (Sotheby's International Realty)
Comedian Joan Rivers moved to her Upper East Side penthouse after the death of her husband, but she wasn’t always alone there. In an episode of Celebrity Ghost Stories, she shared the story of how she brought in a professional to help her deal with Mrs. Spencer, the ghost of a former resident thought to be a niece of J.P. Morgan. Mrs. Spencer apparently messed with her electrical appliances, but the haunting stopped after Ms. Rivers hung an old portrait of Mrs. Spencer in the building’s lobby.

Architect: J.G. Glover | Built in 1851
Neighborhood: Clinton Hill
25 Condos | 5 Floors

320-Washington-Avenue-01 All images of Graham Condo via Compass
To hear “The Graham Home for Old Ladies,” as 320 Washington Avenue is still sometimes called to this day, one imagines a genteel atmosphere behind its Romanesque Revival facade. However, it wasn’t all tea parties and knitting circles. In 1887, a nurse resigned after accusing a matron and another nurse of abusing the residents. Several others weighed in, and one doctor even said that “old people are worse than children.” No evidence of abuse was found and the incident faded away, but neighborhood children would call it “the spooky building” in the years it sat abandoned before being converted to a luxury condominium. The interiors bear little resemblance to the olden days, but the exterior and grounds have been restored to their former glory.

Architect: Andrew Lockwood | Built in 1843
Neighborhood: West Village
1 Unit | 4 Floors

267-West-11th-Street-01 267 West 11th Street (Sotheby's International Realty)
In November 2022, the Greek Revival mansion at 267 West 11th Street sold for $23 million in an off-market deal. The buyer was not identified, nor is it clear whether they knew one of the more sordid chapters in its history. In 1893, well-known madam Annie Sutherland died suddenly in the basement apartment. Her ex-husband was found to have poisoned her with belladonna, and he was sentenced to death by electrocution.

Architect: Alexander Jackson Davis | Built in 1881
Neighborhood: Roosevelt Island
500 Rentals | 13 Floors

The Octagon, 888 Main Street, Roosevelt Avenue apartments for rent The Octagon (Greystar)
NYC's Spookiest Buildings NYC's Spookiest Buildings (octagonnyc.com)
One of the city's greatest landmarks, the Octagon was designed by Alexander Jackson Davis in 1841 to anchor of the New York Pauper Lunatic Asylum on Blackwell’s Island. The institution's patients were moved to Ward's Island in 1893, and the buildings eventually fell into terrible disrepair and were destroyed by a fire. That island is now Roosevelt Island, and the former insane asylum site hosts a luxury rental building with homes commanding as much as $7,564/month and amenities like a concierge, a pool, a gym, parking, two kids' playrooms, daycare, a movie room, a lounge and free shuttle buses to transit. Scary how things can change over the years!

The-Octagon-Leasing The Octagon Leasing (https://octagonnyc.com/)
The Octagon-Apartments-03 Yea, we know. New York has gone soft. (Credit: The Octagon Leasing)
From the listing: Welcome to the 8 Points of Balanced Living. The oasis at The Octagon of creature comforts and limitless opportunity on Roosevelt Island have been carefully curated to strike in harmony; serve and delight all the parts that make you, you. Apartment #747 features a pantry, modern stainless steel appliances, wood-finished cabinetry, hardwood flooring, spacious walk-in closets, and washer & dryer in-unit. See floor plan and full details here.

More NYC buildings with a spooky rep

30-Morningside Drive 30 Morningside Drive is a partial rental conversion of St. Luke's Hospital's historic buildings

30 Morningside Drive


Four-beds from $9,990/month

The Parkside Brooklyn
125 Parkside Avenue


One-beds from $3,475/month

30-Morningside-Drive-01 30 Morningside Drive (DelShah Capital LLC)
125-Parkside-Avenue-01 The Parkside Brooklyn (Bond New York)

Octagon Leasing Office

Octagon Leasing Office
888 Main Street
New York, NY 10044
(212) 888-XXXX
Map
{{error}}

Related Articles

Future New York

Price Cuts include “Succession” penthouse, Fifth Avenue duplex nearly 50% off, and 14 discounts at Brooklyn Tower

Thursday, November 5, 2026
Carter's Perch

Keeping the witches at bay: How finials add drama —and deterrence— to New York’s skyline

Saturday, October 31, 2026
Roosevelt Island

Scary Good Listings: Availabilities in haunted NYC properties

Saturday, October 24, 2026
Get To Know

Dramatic NYC apartments for sale with sunken living rooms from $369K

Friday, September 25, 2026
Future New York

Price Cuts: Dakota spread once asking $39M drops to $12.5M; Hudson Yards penthouse gets $12M trim

Thursday, September 24, 2026
Great Listings

Two full baths for under $1M: NYC apartments that make sharing easier

Tuesday, November 10, 2026
Goldilocks Blocks

Inside Emmy- and Tony Award-winning actress Ellen Barkin's renovated Village townhouse

Tuesday, November 10, 2026
Get To Know

New HDFC Listings: Newly listed affordable co-ops throughout NYC from $120K

Monday, November 9, 2026

More Rental Deals

Free Rent

NYC's spookiest buildings that you'd totally live in anyway

Free Rent

Best New Financial District Rentals: FIVE amenity-packed buildings in FiDi offering up to 3 months free rent

Free Rent

Scary Good Listings: Availabilities in haunted NYC properties

Leasing Updates

How NYC’s 2026 rent freeze is different from past rent freezes + New affordable housing lotteries with rent-stabilized units

Leasing Updates

The Lotus: Eco-friendly Murray Hill rental gears up for leasing launch and affordable lotto

Grand Opening

As CityPicklePalooza takes over Times Square, see NYC buildings with pickleball and padel courts

Grand Opening

New developments in Murray Hill as Midtown prepares for influx office-to-residential conversions

Updated Amenities / Renovations

The Serrano is renting gracious Upper East Side apartments with beautiful views and updated amenities from $5,395/mo.

Updated Amenities / Renovations

Q&A with Ben Picket on Gotham Organization tech-forward approach to improving luxury rental living

Special Offers

Avalon Fort Greene offering discounts on select units; No-fee rentals from $2,845/month

Special Offers

Security Deposit Discounts at Beatrice Apartments in Chelsea; No Fee Rentals from $3,855/Month

Special Offers

East Harlem's The Heritage on Central Park: Renovated Rentals with Incentives from $2,595/Month