Skip to Content

The Sagamore, 189 West 89th Street: Review and Ratings

at The Northeast corner of Amsterdam Avenue View Full Building Profile

Carter Horsley
Review of 189 West 89th Street by Carter Horsley

This large, beige-brick rental apartment tower was designed by Schuman, Lichtenstein, Claman & Efron for The Related Companies and completed in 1998.

The 20-story building at 189 West 89th Street is known as the Sagamore and has a two-story limestone base the first floor of which is rusticated. It has 265 apartments.

The building has a doorman, a health club, a garage, a sundeck, a recreation room, a canopied entrance and video security and permits small dogs.

This area of the Upper West Side improved dramatically in the 1990's with many new restaurants and boutiques on this avenue and Columbus Avenue and Broadway.

There is excellent crosstown bus service on 86th Street and a subway station at 86th Street and Broadway. This location is midway between Central Park and Riverside Park.

The building has a canopied entrance, a lobby designed by David Rockwell, some terraces, marble baths, a concierge, a 24-hour attended garage, a bicycle room, a storage room, a children's playroom and a lounge.

Key Details
  • No Fee Rental built in 1998
  • Located in Broadway Corridor
  • 265 total apartments 265 total apartments
  • Doorman
  • Pets Allowed