City Hall Tower,
258 Broadway

Overview of City Hall Tower at 258 Broadway

City Hall Tower at 258 Broadway stands as a remarkable piece of New York history, originally constructed in 1900 and designed by the renowned architectural firm John B. Snook & Sons. This 8 story Neo Renaissance building served as the flagship store for Rogers, Peet & Company, one of America's pioneering ready made menswear retailers known for their innovative advertising and quality guaranteed policies. The building is architecturally significant as an early example of steel skeleton framed skyscraper construction influenced by the Chicago school, featuring a clear articulation of the structural grid and restrained classical ornament that distinguished it from other early skyscrapers in New York's original skyscraper district.

After Rogers, Peet closed in the late 1970s, the upper floors were converted into 48 cooperative apartments in 1985, creating one of Tribeca's first loft conversions. The building's prewar construction provides residents with exceptionally high ceilings ranging from 11 to 13+ feet, massive windows, and the solid construction that ensures remarkable quiet. Some apartments feature unique mezzanine levels accessible by spiral staircases, creating dramatic duplex style living spaces with sleeping lofts, libraries, and offices on upper levels.

Apartments showcase the building's loft character with expansive open layouts, some exceeding 1,300 square feet, and distinctive features like exposed brick, hardwood floors, and walls of oversized windows. Several units have been architecturally redesigned with premium finishes including Sub Zero appliances, custom millwork, and marble appointments. The building's crown jewel is a three bedroom penthouse with seven original skylights and a private terrace, offering multiple exposures and exceptional light.

Situated on the prime southwest corner of Broadway and Warren Street, City Hall Tower is located directly across from City Hall Park with immediate access to nearly all major subway lines. The well managed co-op provides modern conveniences including a live-in superintendent, video intercom security, laundry facilities, bike storage, and individual basement storage units. The building welcomes pets and allows subletting with board approval, making it a flexible choice for downtown living in the heart of Tribeca's historic district.