Skip to Content
Butterfield House, 37 West 12th Street: All Sales
Butterfield House, 37 West 12th Street: All Sales
  • Apartments
  • Overview & Photos
  • Maps
  • Ratings & Insider Info
  • Floorplans
  • Sales Data & Comps
  • Similar Buildings
  • Off-Market Listings
  • All Units

Butterfield House, 37 West 12th Street: All Sales

between Fifth Avenue & Sixth Avenue Building Profile

Show All Sales
Unit
Size
Approx. ft2
Most Recent Price
Price / ft2
Most Recent Closing
Total Sales
7D
2 beds 2 baths
-
$2,950,000 -1.5% from ask price
-
Sep 30, 2025
        3
PHH
bed bath
-
$3,995,000
-
Aug 8, 2025
        1
10J
3 beds 3.5 baths
-
$5,650,000
-
Aug 6, 2025
        2
4 beds 4 baths
-
$5,100,000
-
Apr 24, 2025
        1
5J
4 beds 3.5 baths
-
$4,895,000 -2.0% from ask price
-
Feb 27, 2025
        4
2F
2 beds 2 baths
1,450
$2,400,000 -3.8% from ask price
$1,655
 
Dec 17, 2024
        3
1K
1 bed 1 bath
-
$1,700,000
-
Oct 22, 2024
        3
6B
2 beds 2 baths
1,650
$4,025,000 +0.8% from ask price
$2,439
 
Sep 5, 2024
        3
11C
2 beds 2 baths
-
$3,000,000 -7.7% from ask price
-
Aug 1, 2024
        2
12H
2 beds 2 baths
-
$1,975,000 -19.4% from ask price
-
Jul 18, 2024
        2
9C
2 beds 2 baths
-
$3,650,000 +8.1% from ask price
-
Jun 13, 2024
        2
4J
4 beds 3 baths
-
$4,950,000 -0.9% from ask price
-
Jun 11, 2024
        2
2B
2 beds 2 baths
-
$2,585,000 +7.9% from ask price
-
Jun 6, 2024
        1
11D
2 beds 2 baths
-
$2,850,000
-
Jan 18, 2024
        1
5C
2 beds 2 baths
1,600
$2,600,000 +6.1% from ask price
$1,625
 
Dec 7, 2023
        1
PHC
4 beds 3 baths
-
$7,345,000 -5.8% from ask price
-
Oct 19, 2023
        2
11G
2 beds 2 baths
1,600
$2,800,000 +3.9% from ask price
$1,750
 
Jun 8, 2023
        2
6E
3 beds 2 baths
-
$3,610,000 -2.3% from ask price
-
Feb 9, 2023
        2
4G
bed bath
-
$2,575,000
-
Jul 5, 2022
        1
2J
3 beds 2.5 baths
2,200
$3,650,000 -8.6% from ask price
$1,659
 
Feb 9, 2022
        3
3F
2 beds 2 baths
1,400
$2,695,000
$1,925
 
Feb 8, 2022
        1
2H
2 beds 2 baths
-
$2,100,000 +23.5% from ask price
-
Jan 11, 2022
        1
11E
3 beds 3 baths
-
$5,200,000 -9.6% from ask price
-
Sep 1, 2021
        1
2C
2 beds 2 baths
1,600
$1,850,000
$1,156
 
Jul 29, 2021
        1
8CF
4 beds 4.5 baths
3,000
$5,922,500 -5.9% from ask price
$1,974
 
May 26, 2021
        1
7H
2 beds 2 baths
-
$2,825,000 -13.1% from ask price
-
Mar 4, 2021
        2
10F
2 beds 2 baths
-
$2,600,000
-
Feb 26, 2021
        2
9G
2 beds 2 baths
-
$2,340,000 -16.4% from ask price
-
Jan 12, 2021
        1
7G
2 beds 2 baths
-
$2,000,000 -8.9% from ask price
-
Dec 18, 2019
        1
9J
3 beds 2.5 baths
-
$4,460,000 -10.7% from ask price
-
Aug 20, 2019
        1
4K
1 bed 1 bath
-
$1,600,000
-
Dec 19, 2018
        1
9F
2 beds 2 baths
-
$2,900,000 -1.7% from ask price
-
Jul 25, 2018
        2
3H
2 beds 2 baths
-
$1,725,000 -9.0% from ask price
-
Apr 24, 2018
        1
5E
3 beds 3 baths
-
$3,000,000 -29.4% from ask price
-
Dec 28, 2017
        1
12G
2 beds 2 baths
-
$3,100,000
-
Jun 5, 2017
        1
5K
1 bed 1.5 baths
1,170
$1,700,000 -6.8% from ask price
$1,453
 
May 25, 2017
        1
6K
1 bed 1.5 baths
1,170
$1,780,000 -6.1% from ask price
$1,521
 
Oct 13, 2016
        2
7J
3 beds 3.5 baths
-
$3,700,000 -17.7% from ask price
-
Apr 1, 2016
        1
4B
2 beds 2 baths
-
$2,720,000 -4.6% from ask price
-
Mar 8, 2016
        1
2D
2 beds 2 baths
1,350
$2,600,000 -3.7% from ask price
$1,926
 
Oct 15, 2015
        2
4C
2 beds 2 baths
-
$2,750,000
-
May 5, 2015
        1
3K
bed bath
-
$1,200,000
-
May 1, 2015
        1
8C
bed bath
-
$2,800,000
-
Jan 29, 2015
        1
8H
2 beds bath
-
$2,800,000 +7.7% from ask price
-
Jan 9, 2015
        1
7E
3 beds 2.5 baths
-
$3,000,000
-
Nov 25, 2013
        1
5G
2 beds 2.5 baths
1,700
$2,775,000
$1,632
 
Jul 17, 2013
        2
8J
3 beds 3.5 baths
-
$3,500,000
-
Feb 25, 2013
        1
8F
2 beds 2 baths
-
$1,725,000
-
Aug 30, 2012
        1
10C
2 beds 2 baths
1,600
$2,050,000
$1,281
 
Aug 27, 2012
        1
2 beds 2 baths
1,200
$1,300,000
$1,083
 
Aug 16, 2012
        2
2K
1 bed 2 baths
1,170
$1,250,000
$1,068
 
Jul 24, 2012
        2
6A
2 beds 2 baths
1,650
$1,800,000 -5.0% from ask price
$1,091
 
May 2, 2012
        1
E
bed bath
-
$2,250,000
-
Sep 9, 2011
        1
PHD
2 beds 2.5 baths
1,700
$4,465,000
$2,626
 
Jul 18, 2011
        2
9D
2 beds 2 baths
-
$1,500,000 -9.1% from ask price
-
Feb 16, 2010
        1
3G
2 beds 2 baths
1,630
$1,600,000 -10.9% from ask price
$982
 
Nov 6, 2009
        1
7B
2 beds 2 baths
1,550
$1,800,000
$1,161
 
Jul 31, 2008
        1
6D
2 beds 2 baths
-
$1,700,000
-
Jun 28, 2007
        1
7K
1 bed 1.5 baths
1,180
$960,000
$814
 
Jun 13, 2006
        1
1H
2 beds 2 baths
1,246
$835,000
$670
 
May 11, 2006
        2
9H
2 beds 2 baths
-
$1,500,000
-
Dec 3, 2004
        1
10H
2 beds 2 baths
-
$1,575,000
-
May 24, 2004
        1
2E
2 beds 2.5 baths
-
$1,500,000
-
Jan 21, 2004
        1
4H
2 beds 2 baths
1,300
$965,000
$742
 
Jan 8, 2004
        1
11H
bed bath
-
$760,000
-
Jan 7, 2004
        1
2G
2 beds 2 baths
-
$1,150,000
-
Dec 1, 2003
        1
4F
bed bath
-
$800,000
-
Jan 2, 2003
        1
One Williamsburg Wharf
between South 11th Street & Division Avenue
Williamsburg
Radiant waterfront condos from $715K. Over 20,000 SF of resort-style amenities. 6sqft’s 2024 Building of the Year. 45% Sold | Summer 2025 closings.
Learn More