Skip to Content
The Abbey Condominium, 205 East 16th Street, NYC - Condo Apartments
The Abbey Condominium, 205 East 16th Street, NYC - Condo Apartments
  • Apartments
  • Overview & Photos
  • Maps
  • Ratings & Insider Info
  • Floorplans
  • Sales Data & Comps
  • Similar Buildings
205 East 16th Street
NEW DEVELOPMENT: OPENED IN 2006

The Abbey Condominium,
205 East 16th Street

Condo located in Gramercy Park, between Third Avenue & Rutherford Place  Map

$1,135 Avg. price/ft2 Apts. For Sale
  • Apartments For Sale (1)
  • Recent Sales (7)
  • All Units in Building (31)
Unit #
Beds
Baths
Size
Price / Ft2
Price
Listed on
Days on Market
Unit #
Beds
Baths
Size
Closing Price
Price / Ft2
Asking Price
Sold on
View Full Sales History

Overview of The Abbey Condominium at 205 East 16th Street

The Abbey Condominium at 205 East 16th Street is a striking Romanesque Revival landmark that blends history with modern luxury. Originally built in 1888 as the parish house of St. George’s Church, it was designed by Charles Otto Blesch with interiors by Leopold Eidlitz. Its rugged, castle-like presence—complete with brownstone façades, arched openings, finials, and a prominent pyramid roof—makes it one of the most distinctive buildings in Gramercy.

Converted into 31 condominium residences in 2005 by Herbert W. Hirsch Enterprises Inc., the Abbey offers a unique living experience steeped in New York history. Its location, adjacent to the gated Stuyvesant Square Park, places residents in the heart of one of the city’s most charming and historically rich neighborhoods. Nearby, the bustling Union Square Greenmarket, Paragon Sports, and the quaint shops and restaurants of Gramercy and Irving Place add to its appeal.

The Abbey Condominium provides modern comforts while maintaining its historic charm. Amenities include a full-time doorman, video security, a live-in superintendent, and a pet-friendly policy. Each apartment is unique, many featuring dramatic double-height ceilings, stained glass windows, and intricate architectural details that nod to the building’s ecclesiastical past. Washer/dryer units are included in all residences.

St. George’s Church has deep roots in New York’s religious and social history. Established as a chapel of Trinity Church in 1749, it became an independent Episcopal parish in 1822 and relocated to Stuyvesant Square in 1846. The church’s towering spires, visible from the East River, once served as a beacon for the neighborhood.

The church played a significant role in social reform, led by the Rev. William Stephen Rainsford in the late 19th century. Rainsford abolished pew rentals, expanded social services, and launched outreach programs for the city’s poor. J.P. Morgan, a prominent congregant and senior warden, financially supported these efforts. In fact, the land for the Abbey was gifted to the church by Morgan himself for just one dollar.

St. George’s Church has also been a venue for high-profile weddings, including Juliet Morgan’s 1894 wedding, which The New York Times described as “the most fashionable and beautiful of all the Spring weddings.” Later, in 1957, the church hosted the nuptials of Ann Phipps and Constantine Sidamon-Eristoff, linking it once again to American aristocracy.

While the church’s congregation merged with others in 1975, its former parish house found new life as a residential haven. It briefly served as a women’s residence in the 1960s before its eventual transformation into The Abbey Condominium. Today, it remains one of the most architecturally unique and historically significant buildings in Gramerc.

Year Built
1888
Converted: 2015
Apartments
31
Floors
5
Pets: Allowed
Neighborhood
Min Down
20%
31Apartments
View All Past
Sales & Rentals
in Building

Amenities

  • Pre War
  • Resident Storage
  • Central AC
  • Garden
  • Washer/Dryer in building
  • Elevator
  • Landmarked
  • Live-In Superintendent
  • Terraces / Balconies

Shh... Many units sell without being publicly listed.

Explore off-market possibilities at The Abbey Condominium – inquire to find out about residences with owners open to private offers!

{ "key" : "AIzaSyDquABdSLhathmwfnoTcYwA1BY6coZZyZk", "lat": 40.73461, "lng": -73.9856, "marker": { "icon": "https://img3.cityrealty.com/neo/i/w/amenities/base.png" } }

Nearby Subways

  1. L
at 3rd Ave and 14th 0.12 miles
  1. N
  2. Q
  3. R
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
at 4th Ave and 15th 0.23 miles

Carter’s Review

"The rugged fantasy castle of Abbey Condominium at 205 East 16th Street between Third Avenue and Rutherford Place on the west side of Stuyvesant Park was originally the parish house of St. George’s Church next door.

It was erected in 1888 and designed by Charles Otto Blesch in Romanesque Revival style with interiors by Leopold Eidlitz."
Read Full Review

Pros & Cons

  • Converted Romanesque Revival parish house
  • Close to many restaurants on Irving Place
  • Steps from Stuyvesant Park
  • Many architectural details retained
  • All apartments are different
  • Pet friendly
  • Live-in superintendent
  • Full-time doorman
  • Close to Subway
  • No fitness center
  • No balconies
  • No garage
  • No roof deck

CityRealty Rating

28
/44
Architecture
+
27
/36
Location
+
13
/39
Features
+
9
Editor’s Points
=
77
CITYREALTY
RATING
  • How is the CityRealty Rating calculated?

    Architecture
    • 30+ remarkable
    • 20-29 distinguished
    • 11-19 average
    • < 11 below average
    Location
    • 27+ remarkable
    • 18-26 distinguished
    • 9-17 average
    • < 9 below average
    Features
    • 22+ remarkable
    • 16-21 distinguished
    • 9-15 average
    • < 9 below average

Sales History by Apartment Size

View Full Closing History
Show:

Pricing Comparison of Similar Buildings

View Detailed Comparison
The Treadwell
between Second Avenue & Third Avenue
Lenox Hill
Comfortable elegance on the Upper East Side. Whole-life amenities + complimentary 1-year memberships to Sollis Health and Omacasa | Immediate occupancy
Learn More