The land use committee of Community Board 6 last night passed a resolution that called for the restoration of the grand former Psychiatric Building at Bellevue Hospital and its placement on National Register of Historic Places, according to an article yesterday at DNAinfo by Amy Zimmer.
"The hospital space - currently operating as an 850-bed men's homeless shelter - has been the subject of redevelopment proposals since the 1980s, when developers wanted to raze the building and replace it with a market rate residential tower," the article said.
The city's most recent idea, it continued, was to transform the dilapidated building on East 29th Street and First Avenue in the Kips Bay area "into a glittering hotel and conference center," and that vision "was shelved in the spring, after the Department of Homeless Services stalled its relocation search as the economy tanked and shelter demand spiked."
"The city dropped the ball, and we're trying to pick it up again," said Edward Rubin, chair of CB6's land use committee, which issued a resolution Wednesday night outlining its vision for the building's redevelopment. Residents in the area, the article said, "weren't happy with the hotel tower proposed by the city's Economic Development Corporation. But they're also unhappy with the status quo, so they're trying to jumpstart the process and get their ideas heard. 'Now is the time to do the planning' Rubin said. 'When the market gets stronger [the city will be back with new ideas.'"
"To turn it into a community resource," the committee "suggested using it for extended stays for hospital patients and their families, accommodating seniors with housing or as a senior center, and including uses for nearby medical and scientific institutions. There was no room for the men's shelter in their plan. 'An 850-bed shelter anywhere in the city is not a good idea,' said Rubin, due to its large, concentrated size.'"
The article said that Minna Elias, chief of staff for Rep. Carolyn Maloney, called it "inhumane" to keep the homeless men there, adding that "the Bellevue building is in terrible shape," and that she had "seen men sleeping on the floor in sweltering rooms without A/C during summer."
The Department of Homeless Services, however, the article said, doesn't intend to move the shelter anytime soon.
"Homeless Services meets regularly and works closely with the 30th Street Community Advisory Board," said DHS spokeswoman Heather Janik, "and has kept them up to date on the Agency's need to keep the 30th Street facility open for the time being."
When the city's EDC began soliciting proposals for the hotel two years ago, DHS planned to relocated the Bellevue shelter to Crown Heights - an idea that generated a great deal of controversy.
Rep. Maloney's office supported the community's efforts to move things forward, Elias said, emphasizing the area's need for senior services. "It is a community with a huge number of ageing people, but there is nowhere to age in place," she said. "CB6 has no assisted living and no sub-acute care facilities, yet we have all these hospitals. So people leave one of these hospitals and then have to leave the neighborhood. "Here's a community that needs services and here's a building that needs love and care," she continued.
"The hospital space - currently operating as an 850-bed men's homeless shelter - has been the subject of redevelopment proposals since the 1980s, when developers wanted to raze the building and replace it with a market rate residential tower," the article said.
The city's most recent idea, it continued, was to transform the dilapidated building on East 29th Street and First Avenue in the Kips Bay area "into a glittering hotel and conference center," and that vision "was shelved in the spring, after the Department of Homeless Services stalled its relocation search as the economy tanked and shelter demand spiked."
"The city dropped the ball, and we're trying to pick it up again," said Edward Rubin, chair of CB6's land use committee, which issued a resolution Wednesday night outlining its vision for the building's redevelopment. Residents in the area, the article said, "weren't happy with the hotel tower proposed by the city's Economic Development Corporation. But they're also unhappy with the status quo, so they're trying to jumpstart the process and get their ideas heard. 'Now is the time to do the planning' Rubin said. 'When the market gets stronger [the city will be back with new ideas.'"
"To turn it into a community resource," the committee "suggested using it for extended stays for hospital patients and their families, accommodating seniors with housing or as a senior center, and including uses for nearby medical and scientific institutions. There was no room for the men's shelter in their plan. 'An 850-bed shelter anywhere in the city is not a good idea,' said Rubin, due to its large, concentrated size.'"
The article said that Minna Elias, chief of staff for Rep. Carolyn Maloney, called it "inhumane" to keep the homeless men there, adding that "the Bellevue building is in terrible shape," and that she had "seen men sleeping on the floor in sweltering rooms without A/C during summer."
The Department of Homeless Services, however, the article said, doesn't intend to move the shelter anytime soon.
"Homeless Services meets regularly and works closely with the 30th Street Community Advisory Board," said DHS spokeswoman Heather Janik, "and has kept them up to date on the Agency's need to keep the 30th Street facility open for the time being."
When the city's EDC began soliciting proposals for the hotel two years ago, DHS planned to relocated the Bellevue shelter to Crown Heights - an idea that generated a great deal of controversy.
Rep. Maloney's office supported the community's efforts to move things forward, Elias said, emphasizing the area's need for senior services. "It is a community with a huge number of ageing people, but there is nowhere to age in place," she said. "CB6 has no assisted living and no sub-acute care facilities, yet we have all these hospitals. So people leave one of these hospitals and then have to leave the neighborhood. "Here's a community that needs services and here's a building that needs love and care," she continued.
Architecture Critic
Carter Horsley
Since 1997, Carter B. Horsley has been the editorial director of CityRealty. He began his journalistic career at The New York Times in 1961 where he spent 26 years as a reporter specializing in real estate & architectural news. In 1987, he became the architecture critic and real estate editor of The New York Post.
6sqft delivers the latest on real estate, architecture, and design, straight from New York City.
