Skip to Content
51 Jay Street - Condo in DUMBO
51 Jay Street - Condo in DUMBO
  • Apartments
  • Overview & Photos
  • Maps
  • Ratings & Insider Info
  • Floorplans
  • Sales Data & Comps
  • Similar Buildings
  • All Units
51 Jay Street
NEW DEVELOPMENT: OPENED IN 2017

51 Jay Street

Doorman condo located in DUMBO, between Plymouth Street & Water Street

51 Jay Street Location Map
  • Apartments For Sale (2) $1,696 Avg. price/ft2
  • Recent Sales (6) $1,374 Avg. price/ft2
  • All Units in Building (74)
Unit #
Beds
Baths
Size
Price / Ft2
Price
Listed on
Days on Market
Unit #
Beds
Baths
Size
Closing Price
Price / Ft2
Asking Price
Sold on
View Full Sales History

Overview of 51 Jay Street

Built in 1905 as an industrial warehouse for Ben Forman & Sons, a manufacturer of silverware and kitchen utensils, 51 Jay Street was converted to 73 residential condominiums in 2014 by Slate Property Group and Adam America Real Estate. The conversion, designed by acclaimed architecture firm ODA, preserves the building's industrial character while introducing modern luxury across seven stories. The double-height lobby features polished concrete flooring and steel rail tracks inspired by the original rails that once carried goods through the building. The property also goes by the address 201 Water Street and is located in DUMBO's landmarked district.

Apartments feature fumed oak herringbone floors, oversized casement windows with blackened steel frames, and ceilings ranging from 9'6" to 9'8" (with double-height ceilings in duplex units). Kitchens are outfitted with custom Aster Cucine cabinetry, La Rochelle Gris marble slab countertops, and a full Gaggenau appliance package including 5 burner cooktops, convection ovens, 42 inch refrigerators, wine coolers, and microwave drawers. Master bathrooms showcase lacquered dark brown vanities with copper detailing, walnut brown marble flooring, and walk-in showers and deep soaking tubs. The duplex penthouses are particularly notable, spanning over 3,000 square feet of interior space with an additional 2,700 square feet of landscaped terraces offering Manhattan Bridge and skyline views. One penthouse was featured in Architectural Digest following a designer renovation by Michael Aiduss. Former NBA player J.J. Redick has lived in the building.

Amenities include a 24 hour concierge, fitness center with dedicated yoga room, residents' lounge, children's playroom, and a landscaped central courtyard designed by Steven Yavanian. The rooftop terrace features an outdoor kitchen, fireplace, and multiple seating areas with sweeping views. Additional conveniences include bicycle storage, a pet washing station, cold storage for deliveries, and on-site parking available for purchase. The building benefits from a 421a tax abatement running through 2033 and maintains pet friendly and investor friendly policies. Located two blocks from Brooklyn Bridge Park and near the A, C, F, 2, and 3 subway lines, the building sits among DUMBO's historic cobblestone streets with easy access to Time Out Market, Jane's Carousel, and the neighborhood's collection of galleries, restaurants, and shops.

Year Built
2016
Apartments
74
Floors
6
Pets: Allowed
Neighborhood
Min Down
20%
74Apartments
View All Past
Sales & Rentals
in Building

Amenities

  • Attended Lobby
  • FT Doorman
  • Resident Storage
  • Central AC
  • Rooftop Terrace
  • Washer/Dryer in building
  • Elevator
  • Mail Room
  • Children's Playroom
  • Lounge
  • Fitness Center
  • Rooftop Terrace
  • On-Site Parking
  • Outdoor Entertainment Space
  • Courtyard
  • In-Unit Washer/Dryer
  • Live-In Superintendent
  • Historic District
{ "key" : "AIzaSyDquABdSLhathmwfnoTcYwA1BY6coZZyZk", "lat": 40.70341, "lng": -73.98628, "marker": { "icon": "https://img3.cityrealty.com/neo/i/w/amenities/base.png" } }

Nearby Subways

  1. F
at Jay 0.26 miles
  1. J
  2. Z
  3. 2
  4. 3
  5. 4
  6. 5
  7. A
  8. C
at Cadman Plaza West and Cranberry 0.36 miles

Pros & Cons

  • Full time doorman and concierge with live-in superintendent
  • Converted 1905 industrial warehouse
  • Designed by acclaimed ODA architectural firm
  • Aster Cucine custom cabinetry
  • Gaggenau appliance package in kitchens
  • La Rochelle Gris marble countertops
  • Oak herringbone floors
  • Oversized casement windows
  • In-unit washer and dryer
  • Rooftop terrace with outdoor kitchen and fireplace
  • Fitness center with dedicated yoga room
  • Children's playroom
  • Landscaped courtyard garden designed by Steven Yavanian
  • Pet washing and grooming station
  • Double-height attended lobby with historic steel tracks
  • Bicycle storage room
  • On-site parking available
  • 421a tax abatement through 2033
  • Prime DUMBO location near Brooklyn Bridge Park
  • No balconies
  • Primary subway access limited to F train

CityRealty Rating

25
/44
Architecture
+
25
/36
Location
+
16
/39
Features
+
8
Editor’s Points
=
74
CITYREALTY
RATING
  • How is the CityRealty Rating calculated?

    Architecture
    • 30+ remarkable
    • 20-29 distinguished
    • 11-19 average
    • < 11 below average
    Location
    • 27+ remarkable
    • 18-26 distinguished
    • 9-17 average
    • < 9 below average
    Features
    • 22+ remarkable
    • 16-21 distinguished
    • 9-15 average
    • < 9 below average

Sales History by Apartment Size

View Full Closing History
Show:

Pricing Comparison of Similar Buildings

View Detailed Comparison

Noteworthy Residents

Notable past and present residents at 51 Jay Street

Editorial Coverage

Alternate Addresses

  • 176 Plymouth Street
  • 178 Plymouth Street
  • 180 Plymouth Street
  • 182 Plymouth Street
  • 184 Plymouth Street
  • 186 Plymouth Street
Bergen Brooklyn
between 3rd Avenue & 4th Avenue
Boerum Hill
World-class design, rooted in local charm. Crafted facade by Frida Escobedo | Textured interiors by Workstead. Early 2025 Occupancy.
Learn More