Skip to Content
CityRealty Logo
Jeffrey Gershon of the Gershon Company has acquired the five-story 19th Century building at 181 Sullivan Street in Greenwich Village and plans to convert it residential condominiums.

The handsome property, which dates to before the Civil War, formerly housed the Sullivan Street Playhouse where ?The Fantastiks? ran for more than 40 years until 2002.

Mr. Gershon acquired the property several months ago for about $4,250,000 and the conversion plan calls for a duplex garden apartment and three full-floor apartments.

A rendering of the project indicates that it will have a very modern glass and black metal fa?ade. Kitchens will be by Valcucine.

The mid-block building is between Bleecker and West Houston Streets on the east side of Sullivan Street. Much of the west side of this block is part of the landmark enclave of townhouses that share a communal garden between Sullivan and Thompson Streets.

James P. Nelson and Brock A. Emmetsberger of Massey Knakal Realty Services were the brokers in the sale of the property.

According to the Greenwich Village Society for Historic Preservation, ?in the 1830s, the entire east side of this street (known as Varick place until the mid-20th Street) had a row of handsome Greek Revival rowhouses, of which 181 (the Sullivan Street Playhouse) and 179 (The American Legion Club?) are the best surviving vestiges. 179 is in fact largely intact, while 181 was remodeled significantly with its stoop removed and the current theater inserted inside. Prior to its conversion to a theater, long-time Village residents report that the building home to a nightclub and speakeasy operated by Jimmy Kelley, a long-time Greenwich Village Democratic Party boss.?

A call by CityRealty.com today to Mr. Gershon was not returned so details as to pricing and when sales begins and who is the architect are not yet available, nor whether the building might be called ?Fantastik.?

Related Articles

Future New York

Landmarks praises residential conversion/restoration of NoMad's Baudouine Building, Seeks revisions to rooftop addition

Today, June 23, 2026
Iconic Addresses

Paul Newman's parkside office sells 47% over ask; Pre-war condo conversions lead Manhattan sales

Today, June 23, 2026
Get To Know

What is a sponsor unit? Pros, cons, and NYC apartments with no board approval required from $165K

Today, June 23, 2026
Future New York

NYC contracts led by $18.5M Upper East Side mansion and a bespoke Billionaires' Row condo

Today, June 23, 2026
Get To Know

How property values are assessed in NYC + Great new listings with open houses from $445K

Saturday, June 20, 2026
Get To Know

Swim with a View: 30 Manhattan buildings with high-floor swimming pools and fitness centers

Saturday, June 20, 2026
Future New York

Brick is Back: NYC developments revive the warmth of masonry; See Morris Adjmi's new design for 277 Canal Street

Friday, June 19, 2026
Coney Island

Knicks in Five: 35 NYC condo and rental buildings with basketball courts

Thursday, June 18, 2026
Architecture Critic Carter Horsley Since 1997, Carter B. Horsley has been the editorial director of CityRealty. He began his journalistic career at The New York Times in 1961 where he spent 26 years as a reporter specializing in real estate & architectural news. In 1987, he became the architecture critic and real estate editor of The New York Post.