The Woolworth Tower Residences, 2 Park Place: Review and Ratings

Review of 2 Park Place by Carter Horsley

The Woolworth Tower Residences comprise 33 condominium apartments at the top of the 60-story Woolworth Building at 233 Broadway facing City Hall Park.

The 792-foot-high building is one of the world’s most famous skyscrapers and was the tallest in the world when it was built in 1912.  It held that title until it was surpassed in 1930 by the Chrysler Building, which lost the title 18 months later to the Empire State Building.

Known as the “Cathedral of Commerce,” it was designed by Cass Gilbert, who also designed the sumptuous United States Custom House at the foot of Broadway.

It abounds in Gothic-style tracery and Philip Johnson, the architect, told Carter B. Horsley, when he was at The New York Times, that it was his favorite skyscraper.

The residential portion of the building has a 2 Park Place address.

The building was designated a city landmark in 1982 and its stupendous lobby spaces were designated a city interior landmark the following year.

Bottom Line

One of the world’s most distinguished and historic skyscrapers, the apartments offer spectacular views in most directions although there are some taller buildings, including the World Trade Center and the Four Seasons Hotel to the west.

Description

Gilbert believed that the building’s “height should be recognized, insisted upon and expresses by vertical lines” and he opted for “the flamboyant Gothic tracery and ornament of the latter part of the 15^th and 16^th centuries, light, graceful, dedicated and flame-like.”  He once remarked that the building had been called “The Cathedral of Commerce,” but maintained that “there was no intention of making it anything like a cathedral and in fact it bears no resemblance to a cathedral in the plan or exterior design or in any other respect.  There are many medieval civic buildings to which it might be likened such as the Halls at Middleburg and Alkmaar in Holland, the City Hall in Brussels, the Hotel de Ville in Compiegne, the Cloth Hall at Ypres (destroyed in the great war) and many others all of which have towers of proportionately great height although of course very much smaller than the Woolworth tower….It was my thought …that I must express the idea of a civic or commercial building rather than of an ecclesiastical one….Woolworth’s first inclination was towards granite as the exterior material.  Gilbert suggested limestone as a cheaper alternative.  Eventually, however, terra cotta was chosen for all but the first four stories of the building where were clad in limestone…..Gilbert was interested in terra cotta because it was a think pliable material, with polychromatic possibilities, which, to his mind, could never be mistaken for a structural element. By wrapping the steel-age structure in an ornamental, polychromatic, thin terra-cotta skin, Gilbert felt he was justifying the building’s structure nature….”As finally completed, the building was lit ‘from the thirty-first to the sixtieth story.  …The light has since been change.

The building, which is between Park Place and Barclay Street has a 30-story base and a 30-story tower and the tower has two setbacks and culminate in a pyramidal roof and four tourelles that have been substantially altered from their original condition.

The tower pyramid was originally gilded.

The bank’s entrance was called the marble hall and was always intended to center on a staircase rising to the mezzanine level offices.

Six angled piers are carried down into the base and four end in corbels carved as allegorical human faces apparently representing the four continents of Africa, America, Europe and Asia.

The interior landmark designation report noted that “Gilbert’s elaborate decorative scheme was worked out in fine marbles , Gothic bronze tracery used even in the elevator doors and mail chutes, a colored glass ceiling in the Marble Hall, sculpted grotesques in both the Hall and the arcade, exquisite abstract floral mosaics reminiscent of early Christian  designs in the ceiling, and painting triptychs in the mezzanine spaces over the north-south corridor of the arcade….the painted tryptychs in the galleries portray allegorical figures of Commerce and Labor; they were the work of Paul Jenewein. The glass ceiling in the marble hall is inscribed with the names of great commercial nations.  The grotesque figures supporting the arcade galleries, by Tom Johnson, a popular caricaturist of the day, portray not only Woolworth paying for the building with nickels and dimes, Gilbert holding a model of the building, Lewis Pierson the head of the Irving bank, also Gunwal Aus, the steel engineer holding a beam, Louis Horowitz, the building, and even Edward Hogan, the renting agent.

Amenities

The building has a 24-hour doorman, a full-time concierge, personal mail delivery, an attended garage, bicycle storage, a swimming pool with sauna and hot tub, the Gilbert Lounge on the 29th floor, the Personal Fitness Studio on the 30th floor, and a wine cellar and tasting room.

Apartments

An article at ny.curbed.com August 21, 2014 by Hiten Samtani said that Alchemy Properties filed an offering plan for the condominiums with the New York State Attorney General’s office with a total sales price of about $443.7 million, including $110 million and the multi-story penthouse known as “The Pinnacle” that will contain more than 9,400-square feet of space and 499 square feet of outdoor space. 

Kitchens have custom Dada cabinetry crafted by the Molteni Group, Calacatta Caldia marble countertops and backsplashes, solid oak herringbone floors and Miele appliances.

Master bathrooms have Calacatta Prima marble floors, walls and surrounds with Nero Marquina marble accent trim, radiant heat floors, steam showers, and Dornbracht platinum-finish fittings with Nanz hardward.

The Pinnacle is a 7-level unit with three bedrooms.

It has two bedrooms and three, angled, walk-in, corner closets with windows on the 50^th floor, a large gallery leading to a 27-foot-wide dining room adjacent to a corner breakfast room with windows next to a 17-foot-long enclosed kitchen with an island and windows and an adjoining butler’s pantry and a bedroom and a corner laundry room with windows on the 51^st floor, a great room with 1,350 square feet on the 53^rd floor, and the 55^th through the 58^th floors will contain a library or media room and an observation deck.

The average price per square foot in the offering plan was $4,172 a square foot, according to the article with prices beginning at $3.875million for a 1,290-square-foot unit on the 44^th floor.

Pavilion A on the 29^th floor has 6,327 square feet with four bedrooms and 4.5 bathrooms and 1,227 of terraces.

Pavilion B on the 30^th floor has 5,127 square feet with 3 bedrooms and 835 square feet of terraces.

Apartment 31A is a five-bedroom unit with a very large library/living/dining room and 6,056 square feet of space with four bedrooms and 638 square feet of two narrow terraces.

Apartment A on the 32nd through the 39th floors and the 41st floor is a three-bedroom unit with 3,282 square feet with an entry foyer that leads to a 35-foot-long great room adjacent to a 16-foot-long kitchen.  The master bedroom is 20 feet long and has a 13-foot-long walk-in closet.

Apartment 43A is a three-bedroom unit with a very large and long living/library and wrap-around terraces.

Apartment B on floors 32 through 39 and 41 is a two-bedroom unit with 2,548 square feet with an 18-foot-wide entry foyer that leads to a 25-foot-wide Great room adjacent to a pass-through, 13-foot-wide, windowed kitchen,  A long galley leads from the foyer to the 18-foot-wide master bedroom that has a 9-foot-wide walk-in closet and a 13-foot-long master bath.

Apartment A on floors 44 through 47 is a two-bedroom unit with 2,425 square feet with a 24-foot-long Great room that opens onto a 13-foot-long library and an 18-foot-long windowed kitchen with sliding pocket doorsl

Apartment B on floors 44 through 47 is a one-bedroom unit with a 17-foot-square living/dining room with a narrow, 27-foot-long, enclosed kitchen alcove.

History

The building was designed as the corporate headquarters for the F. W. Woolworth Company, the “5- and 10-cent Store,” and the Irving National Bank.

In its designation report, the New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission provided the following commentary about the Woolworth Building:

“In 1913, Cass Gilbert’s graceful, Gothic-style, terra-cotta clad, sixty-story tower became the prototype for the tall romantic skyscraper that permanently transformed the skyline of New York and bec…[a]me the most potent image of twentieth-century urban America.”

“…The Woolworth Building became a symbol not just of Woolworth’s personal success, but also of the new twentieth-century phenomenon of mass commerce….The Woolworth Building stands as a watershed in the history of the American skyscraper….Although long since stripped of its ‘world’s tallest’ title, the Woolworth Building remains one of the great symbols of twentieth-century America, and one of New York’s and the country’s outstanding landmarks.”

Mr. Woolworth’s “first venture, ‘The Great Five  Center Store’ in Utica, met with little success; he…moved to Lancaster, Pennsylvania,…increased the scope of his goods by including items for ten cents, and on June 6, 1879 opened the first ‘Woolworth’s 5 and 10 Cent Store.’…Attributing his success in Lancaster in part to the ‘thriftiness of the Pennsylvania Dutch,’ Woolworth began to open similar stores elsewhere in the state.  Stores in Harrisburg and New York did not succeed, but one in Scranton, opened in 1880, did….Since most of his suppliers were in New York he moved to the city in 1886….In 1888, he moved his office into the Sun Building at Chambers Street and Broadway….In pursuit of cheaper goods he began to go to Europe, where labor and material costs were often lower, and made his first buying trip thee in 1890.  It was in the course of these tripe s that he was first exposed to European architecture; on his first visit to London he wrote home that he was tremendously impressed by the Houses of Parliament, the buildings which twenty years later he hoped to emulate in his Woolworth Building….The first Manhattan ‘5 and 10’ was at 259 Sixth Avenue near 17^th Street, in the heart of the then fashionable ‘Ladies’ Mile’ shopping district.  The chain grew to 59 stores by the end of 1900….In 1910, he merged his company with those of four competitors to create the F. W. Woolworth Company, a corporation controlling all 611 stories….Woolworth began planning his new headquarters in 1910….From the start, the building was also intended to a headquarters for the Irving National Bank, today the Irving Trust Company. ….Woolworth originally intended to build a standard twelve- to sixteen-story office building on a corner site at Broadway and Park Place….At first the building was increased to twenty stores in order to be taller than the Pulitzer building on the other side of City Hall Park.  By September of 1910, the proposed design called for a twenty-five story base supported a forty-story tower on its east front, rising about 550 feet….Soon thereafter, Woolworth resolved to go still higher.  The Singer Building, completed by architect Ernest Flagg in 1907, rose 612 feet on a site just a few blocks south of Woolworth’s project….The building was announced publicly in November 1910 as a forty-five story tower rising 625 feet….There still remained, however, the Metropolitan Life Insurance Tower on Madison Square, which, when competed by architects Napoleon LeBrun & Sons in 1909, had become the successor to the title of world’s tallest building….”

Mr. Gilbert, the architect, reportedly asked Mr. Woolworth how high should his building be and was told to “make it fifty feet higher than the Metropolitan tower.”

“The ‘5 and 10’ offices hardly required such an enormous office building, nor could the Woolworth Building be considered a symbol of the frugality which Woolworth hoped for his customers,” the designation report continued, adding that “Its creation has to be seen, rather, in light of Woolworth’s changing conceptions of himself and his company….Woolworth was no long just a merchant he was becoming recognized member of New York’s wealthy elite.  He had already left his middle-class Brooklyn neighborhood to live in the Hotel Savoy on Fifth Avenue at Grand Army Place, but in 1901 he built  a mansion at 990 Fifth Avenue….Later he built an entire compound of townhouses for his family along East 80^th Street, and bought a Glen Cove estate which he renamed ‘Winfield Hall.’’’

Gilbert joined the New York firm of McKim, Mead & White in 1880, but returned to St. Paul two years later to set up his own practice with James Knox Taylor, who was a fellow M.I.T. graduate.  Mead urged Gilbert to become Daniel Burnham’s new partner after the death of John Welburn Root, but Gilbert chose to remain in St. Paul where he became president of the Minnesota Chapter of the American Institute of Architects.  In 1895, he won the competition to design a new Minnesota state capital, which, according to the designation report, “laid the groundwork for his 1899 winning entry in the New York Customs House competition” and in 1900 he moved to New York.    He would design the Broadway-Chambers Building in 1900 and the West Street Building in 1907, the Federal Courthouse in New York in 1934 and the Supreme Court Building in Washington in 1935.