Price Cuts: Amy Schumer's and Bill Cosby's homes get reductions; Park Ave penthouse with pool now $2M off

Thursday, Jul 10, 2025 By CityRealty Staff, CityRealty contributor

From July 1-7, 2025, fewer than 200 condos, co-ops, condops, and townhouses in core New York City areas experienced price reductions. These included 19 Cranberry Street in Brooklyn Heights, whose exteriors were famously used as the Castorini family home in Academy Award-winning film Moonstruck. More recently, it was purchased by actress/writer Amy Schumer.

Former owner Edwards Rullman was the chairman of the Historic Preservation Committee of the Brooklyn Heights Association, and a key figure in the neighborhood's designation as New York City's first historic district. Ms. Schumer bought the house in June 2022, but listed it for $14 million less than three years later to move closer to her son's school in Manhattan. The price reduction brings it down to $12.75 million.

If the house goes for the reduced price, Ms. Schumer would roughly break even, having paid $12.5 million ($1.5 million over the last ask) for it. However, this doesn't account for a backyard renovation by Michael Van Valkenburgh, whose portfolio includes the nearby Brooklyn Bridge Park. He replaced the brick patio with turf and added a children's playset. 6sqft notes that the backyard can serve as a gated parking spot; additional features include a terrace overlooking the backyard, an eat-in kitchen, a full-floor primary suite, a basement-level home gym, and a custom wine cellar.

-8.9% | -$1,250,000

19 Cranberry Street, #TH
$12,750,000

Brooklyn Heights | Townhouse | 5 Bedrooms, 3.5 Baths | 5,568 ft²

19 Cranberry Street, #TH (Modlin Group LLC)

From the Listing: Perfectly positioned on the coveted corner of Cranberry and Willow Streets in the Brooklyn Heights Historic District, this 26’ wide townhouse with a driveway on Willow Street opens onto the enclosed garden, which can be repurposed as private parking. Built in 1829 in a classic Federal-style, the exterior of this incredible home belies the impeccably restored interior, including grand rooms with high ceilings and restored crown moldings, hand-carved and milled trim, and a grand total of 30 windows, ensuring all-day natural light. See floor plan and full details here.

In Manhattan, disgraced comedian Bill Cosby adjusted the price of an Upper East Side townhouse purchased in his name but lived in by his late son Ennis Cosby. The four-story house in the Treadwell Farm Historic District was initially listed for just under $7 million in April 2025, but the reduction brings it down to $6.75 million. Mansion Global announced the reduction and noted that the Cosbys are facing foreclosure on the house following a lawsuit from their lender.

-3.6% | -$249,999

243 East 61st Street, #TH
$6,750,000

Lenox Hill | Townhouse | 6+ Bedrooms, 4.5 Baths | 5,000 ft²

243 East 61st Street, #TH (Corcoran Group)

From the Listing: Welcome to this distinguished 19th-century townhouse, a true architectural gem located in the heart of Lenox Hill's iconic Treadwell Farm Historic District. Offering a generous 20-foot-wide footprint and spanning 5,000 square feet, this six-bedroom, six-bath residence defines timeless urban sophistication. While condos and co-ops often trade character for convenience, townhouse living offers something entirely different: privacy, scale, and authentic architectural grace. See floor plan and full details here.

Noble LIC (Corcoran Group)

Also of note, four units had their prices reduced at Noble LIC, a new development boutique condominium in the Dutch Kills section of Long Island City. The building is nearly 80% sold since launching sales in spring 2024, and the price-reduced one- and two-bedroom units represent some of the last sponsor availabilities in the building. It is open for immediate occupancy.

All 46 studio to two-bedroom residences feature private outdoor space and are accessed via keyless entry. Interiors by Porcelanosa feature abundant natural light from oversized windows, wide plank Lutier Grey engineered hardwood floors, custom kitchens with porcelain slab waterfall countertops and Bertazzoni appliances, custom Porcelanosa primary baths with radiant heated floors, and Electrolux stackable washers and dryers.

-5.2% | -$54,000

Noble LIC, #2A
$985,000

Long Island City | Condominium | 1 Bedroom, 1 Bath | 616 ft²

Noble LIC, #2A (Corcoran Group)

From the Listing: Noble LIC sets a new standard for design excellence in Long Island City. Residences have high ceilings, every home has an Electrolux stackable washer and dryer, 100% of the homes offer private outdoor space and large European windows fill the spaces with natural light. Each home offers keyless entry by Latch. See floor plan and full details here.

A selection of notable listings, as well as a full chart of last week's price cuts, may be seen below. Please be advised that all figures reflect cumulative price cuts as opposed to the most recent reductions.

Would you like to tour any of these properties?

Just complete the info below.

Select listings with price improvements

-6.9% | -$2,000,000

1110 Park Avenue, #PHTRIPLEX
$27,000,000

Carnegie Hill | Condominium | 5 Bedrooms, Unknown Baths | 7,000 ft²

1110 Park Avenue, #PHTRIPLEX (Sothebys International Realty)

From the Listing: The Penthouse is a stunning 7,000-square-foot five-bedroom, five and a half-bath triplex residence featuring a 1,600-square-foot private rooftop complete with an endless swimming pool overlooking the Jackie Onassis Reservoir, an outdoor kitchen, gas fireplace and beautiful open city views. Additional outdoor features include a 221-square-foot balcony off the living room and nine Juliet balconies throughout. Fully furnished with Italian furniture. See floor plan and full details here.

-5.1% | -$755,000

65 Bedford Street, #TH
$13,995,000

West Village | Townhouse | 5 Bedrooms, 5.5 Baths | 4,200 ft²

65 Bedford Street, #TH (Corcoran Group)

From the Listing: 65 Bedford Street is a charming Greek Revival townhouse located on a historic landmarked West Village block. Beautifully renovated with original details intact, this spacious home offers five bedrooms, a top-floor penthouse atrium suite, five full bathrooms (four of which are en-suite), two half bathrooms, three outdoor spaces, and the highly coveted townhouse feature - an elevator. There is an abundance of outdoor space including a sizable private garden, primary bedroom terrace, and roof deck. See floor plan and full details here.

-7.9% | -$750,000

251 East 61st Street, #TH
$8,750,000

Lenox Hill | Townhouse | 5 Bedrooms, 5.5 Baths | 5,889 ft²

251 East 61st Street, #TH (Brown Harris Stevens Residential Sales LLC)

From the Listing: Brilliantly marrying historic townhouse classicism and the best of modern design today- 251 East 61st Street is a completely reimagined townhouse and carriage house ensemble, a true private compound masterfully conceived by TRA Studio as a cohesive, design-forward single-family residence with guest house. The restoration undertaken by the current owner included expanding the townhome with an additional floor, which houses the primary suite with amazing skyline views. The vertical living was enhanced by the installation of an elevator. See floor plan and full details here.

-16.1% | -$955,000

350 West 71st Street, #PHA
$4,995,000

Riverside Dr./West End Ave. | Condominium | 3 Bedrooms, 3.5 Baths | 2,553 ft²

350 West 71st Street, #PHA (R New York)

From the Listing: Welcome to an extraordinary 2,553-square-foot penthouse, featuring a breathtaking 1,513-square-foot private furnished rooftop. This top floor residence seamlessly combines elegance, privacy, and exceptional design. It offers three spacious bedrooms, each with ample closet space, conveniently outfitted with California Closets built-ins. Additionally, there is a thoughtfully situated home office on the second level for added privacy, along with 3.5 luxurious bathrooms. See floor plan and full details here.

-32% | -$1,550,000

77 Greenwich Street, #39-C
$3,300,000

Financial District | Condominium | 3 Bedrooms, 3.5 Baths | 1,889 ft²

77 Greenwich Street, #39-C (Reuveni LLC)

From the Listing: Every home in this luxury defining condominium features a direct view of the NY Harbor. This brand new three-bedroom, three and a half-bath, 1,905-square-foot home includes floor-to-ceiling crystalline glass windows allowing for an abundance of natural light, stunning water views and soaring ceilings of close to 11’. The gracious entryway features custom millwork and stone flooring. See floor plan and full details here.

-8.9% | -$250,000

The Wellesley, #5B
$2,550,000

Riverside Dr./West End Ave. | Cooperative | 3 Bedrooms, 3 Baths

The Wellesley, #5B (Corcoran Group)

From the Listing: This prewar classic 7 is different from its peers-larger rooms, more closets, abundant light in all rooms (16 windows), a superb floorplan that Schwartz & Gross designed in 1928, and terrific amenities. Entering the apartment from the semi-private elevator vestibule, you are greeted with a large and gracious entry foyer. From the foyer, you are ushered into the perfectly proportioned and large living room and formal dining room. 3 storage units in the basement transfer with the apartment. See floor plan and full details here.

-10% | -$250,000

Sutton Hall, #14B
$2,250,000

Midtown East | Cooperative | 3 Bedrooms, 2 Baths | 2,255 ft²

350 East 57th Street, #14B (Compass)

From the Listing: Residence 14B is a distinguished high-floor residence in a boutique prewar cooperative, offering a blend of classic elegance and modern comfort. Upon entering, a semi-private vestibule leads to a 20-foot entrance gallery with gorgeous marble flooring from Italy in the pattern based on the Church of San Giorgio Maggiore in Venice. The foyer flows seamlessly into a spacious living room and formal dining room, both adorned with oversized windows that provide abundant natural light and offer north and west-facing vistas. See floor plan and full details here.

-7.8% | -$175,000

359 13th Street, #2
$2,075,000

Park Slope | Condominium | 3 Bedrooms, 2 Baths | 1,130 ft²

359 13th Street, #2 (Douglas Elliman Real Estate)

From the Listing: Introducing Unit 2 at 359 13th Street, a stunningly crafted 3-bedroom, 2-bath home built to the highest of standards. The serene ambiance begins with 6-inch wide plank wood floors, creamy lime washed walls, exposed ceiling beams blending perfectly against the backdrop of wood cabinets and the Taj Mahal quartzite island in the kitchen. Abundant natural light from three exposures floods the space, thanks to oversized south-facing windows and rare west-facing side windows. See floor plan and full details here.

-7.2% | -$155,000

The Alwyn Court, #11A
$1,995,000

Midtown West | Cooperative | 2 Bedrooms, 2 Baths

The Alwyn Court, #11A (Compass)

From the Listing: Step into a truly distinctive residence at the iconic Alwyn Court—a home designed for those who appreciate space, light, and culture. This expansive two-bedroom, two-bathroom apartment offers dramatic proportions and a seamless layout ideal for entertaining. With ceilings soaring to 10'5", and oversized windows showcasing open north and east views, the space feels both grand and welcoming. See floor plan and full details here.

-15.1% | -$355,000

The Endicott, #714
$1,995,000

Broadway Corridor | Cooperative | 2 Bedrooms, 2 Baths

The Endicott, #714 (Corcoran Group)

From the Listing: Welcome to Residence #714, a rare gem offering the perfect blend of modern comfort and classic charm in one of Manhattan's most coveted neighborhoods. This 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom residence is a bright and spacious retreat, featuring city-quiet windows that provide peaceful, pin-drop silence amidst the vibrancy of the Upper West Side. Step inside to discover an open layout with refined finishes. Direct access to the private rooftop oasis is provided by a central staircase separating the living room from the dedicated dining space. See floor plan and full details here.

-16.7% | -$350,000

50 West 127th Street, #7B
$1,750,000

Harlem | Condominium | 3 Bedrooms, 2 Baths | 1,756 ft²

50 West 127th Street, #7B (Corcoran Group)

From the Listing: This is a rare opportunity to own a breathtaking, high-floor, Scandinavian-inspired residence that seamlessly blends luxury and space. This one-of-a-kind 3-bedroom, 2-bath home features an expansive layout designed for modern living, with three exposures (north, south and east) and open skyline views in every direction from every room and terrace. A striking vaulted ceiling crowns the spacious living room and second bedroom, enhancing its elegance and depth. A 25-year tax abatement runs through 2033. See floor plan and full details here.

-10.7% | -$170,000

100 United Nations Plaza, #7G
$1,425,000

Turtle Bay/United Nations | Condominium | 2 Bedrooms, 2.5 Baths | 1,256 ft²

100 United Nations Plaza, #7G (Corcoran Group)

From the Listing: Recently renovated, spacious and pin-drop quiet split 2-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom with a private wrap balcony now available at 100 United Nations Plaza, one of Midtown East's premier white-glove, full service condominiums. Boasting three exposures from its floor-to-ceiling windows plus a 105-square-foot private wrap-around balcony, the generous living and dining room will effortlessly accommodate multiple seating areas as well as dining for up to 8 or more guests. See floor plan and full details here.

-11.1% | -$150,001

2 Sutton Place South, #7F
$1,199,999

Beekman/Sutton Place | Cooperative | 2 Bedrooms, 2 Baths

2 Sutton Place South, #7F (Compass)

From the Listing: Classic pre-war two-bedroom, two-bathroom apartment with east, west, and southern exposure is currently being offered for sale in the coveted 2 Sutton Place South cooperative. A grand marble foyer welcomes one into the expansive sunken living room, with beautiful hexagonal wood floors, stunning millwork on every wall, ceiling with original beams and a marble working wood-burning fireplace. See floor plan and full details here.

-8.8% | -$96,000

Coda Condominium, #11A
$999,000

Gramercy Park | Condominium | 1 Bedroom, 1 Bath | 770 ft²

Coda Condominium, #11A (Compass)

From the Listing: Discover one of the best bedroom layouts in the building with this spacious one-bedroom, one-bathroom home, 11A, where floor-to-ceiling windows flood the space with southern light and breathtaking city views. The entryway leads to a generously proportioned living room, ideal for entertaining, seamlessly connected to an open kitchen that features glossy white Italian lacquer cabinetry, honed marble countertops and backsplashes, and top-of-the-line appliances. See floor plan and full details here.

-43.8% | -$741,000

459 West 18th Street, #1
$949,000

Chelsea | Condominium | 2 Bedrooms, 1.5 Baths | 1,693 ft²

459 West 18th Street, #1 (Douglas Elliman Real Estate)

From the Listing: Spacious duplex condo boasts a huge private deck with irrigation system. Interiors feature 9'4" ceilings, polished concrete flooring, kitchen with custom Italian cabinetry and high-end appliances, floor-to-ceiling windows on the upper level, and ultra-private bedrooms on a separate level. Cable and Wi-Fi included in monthly common charges. See floor plan and full details here.

-10.1% | -$80,000

227 West 11th Street, #43
$715,000

West Village | Cooperative | 1 Bedroom, 1 Bath | 350 ft²

227 West 11th Street, #43 (Corcoran Group)

From the Listing: Be the first to enjoy #43's brand new, tasteful renovation. Modern finishes in combination with its original prewar details give this apartment a unique charm, while its inviting layout makes it a pleasant space for hosting. Large windows stream the apartment with light, while the brand new eat-in kitchen featuring Calacatta White Quartz backsplash, custom white cabinetry with abundant storage, and new appliances such as a full-size Bosch dishwasher, leaves the apartment feeling stylish and polished. 6 months of maintenance paid for any contract signed by August 15! See floor plan and full details here.

-6.7% | -$40,000

Southgate, #14G
$559,000

Beekman/Sutton Place | Cooperative | 1 Bedroom, 1 Bath

Southgate, #14G (Elegran LLC)

From the Listing: Welcome to this beautifully designed and fully renovated one-bedroom home at 400 East 52nd Street, nestled on a serene cul-de-sac in the coveted Beekman/Sutton Place neighborhoods. This stunning residence features a private terrace spanning the entire length of the apartment, perfect for outdoor enjoyment. Bathed in natural light from its sunny southern exposure, the home boasts a contemporary and inviting design. See floor plan and full details here.

In this article:

-8.9% | -$1,250,000

19 Cranberry Street, #TH
$12,750,000

-3.6% | -$249,999

243 East 61st Street, #TH
$6,750,000

-5.2% | -$54,000

Noble LIC, #2A
$985,000

Select which properties are of interest to you:

Select listings with price improvements

-6.9% | -$2,000,000

1110 Park Avenue, #PHTRIPLEX
$27,000,000

-5.1% | -$755,000

65 Bedford Street, #TH
$13,995,000

-7.9% | -$750,000

251 East 61st Street, #TH
$8,750,000

-16.1% | -$955,000

350 West 71st Street, #PHA
$4,995,000

-32% | -$1,550,000

77 Greenwich Street, #39-C
$3,300,000

-8.9% | -$250,000

The Wellesley, #5B
$2,550,000

-10% | -$250,000

Sutton Hall, #14B
$2,250,000

-7.8% | -$175,000

359 13th Street, #2
$2,075,000

-7.2% | -$155,000

The Alwyn Court, #11A
$1,995,000

-15.1% | -$355,000

The Endicott, #714
$1,995,000

-16.7% | -$350,000

50 West 127th Street, #7B
$1,750,000

-10.7% | -$170,000

100 United Nations Plaza, #7G
$1,425,000

-11.1% | -$150,001

2 Sutton Place South, #7F
$1,199,999

-8.8% | -$96,000

Coda Condominium, #11A
$999,000

-43.8% | -$741,000

459 West 18th Street, #1
$949,000

-10.1% | -$80,000

227 West 11th Street, #43
$715,000

-6.7% | -$40,000

Southgate, #14G
$559,000

For the Love of Loggias: Rare New York City listings with private outdoor rooms

Sublet or pay up? How homeowners could avoid the 2nd-home tax + Luxury listings for rent in condo/co-op buildings

25 NYC residential buildings with acclaimed in-house restaurants as Polo Bar plans move to 625 Madison

Price Cuts: Four-bed at The Dakota slashed by $3.8M; Majestic 30-foot-wide Brooklyn Heights house trimmed by $500K

In honor of Bastille Day, see NYC's grandest Beaux-Arts and French Renaissance-style buildings

Top 10 new development condos with common roof decks for grilling and lounging

NYC homes with bay windows to let the sun shine in

Taking game night to the next level: 15 NYC condos with elevated game rooms and billiards tables

Price Cuts: Amy Schumer's and Bill Cosby's homes get reductions; Park Ave penthouse with pool now $2M off

In this article:

-8.9% | -$1,250,000 19 Cranberry Street, #TH$12,750,000

-3.6% | -$249,999 243 East 61st Street, #TH$6,750,000

-5.2% | -$54,000 Noble LIC, #2A$985,000

Select which properties are of interest to you:

Select listings with price improvements

-6.9% | -$2,000,000 1110 Park Avenue, #PHTRIPLEX$27,000,000

-5.1% | -$755,000 65 Bedford Street, #TH$13,995,000

-7.9% | -$750,000 251 East 61st Street, #TH$8,750,000

-16.1% | -$955,000 350 West 71st Street, #PHA$4,995,000

-32% | -$1,550,000 77 Greenwich Street, #39-C$3,300,000

-8.9% | -$250,000 The Wellesley, #5B$2,550,000

-10% | -$250,000 Sutton Hall, #14B$2,250,000

-7.8% | -$175,000 359 13th Street, #2$2,075,000

-7.2% | -$155,000 The Alwyn Court, #11A$1,995,000

-15.1% | -$355,000 The Endicott, #714$1,995,000

-16.7% | -$350,000 50 West 127th Street, #7B$1,750,000

-10.7% | -$170,000 100 United Nations Plaza, #7G$1,425,000

-11.1% | -$150,001 2 Sutton Place South, #7F$1,199,999

-8.8% | -$96,000 Coda Condominium, #11A$999,000

-43.8% | -$741,000 459 West 18th Street, #1$949,000

-10.1% | -$80,000 227 West 11th Street, #43$715,000

-6.7% | -$40,000 Southgate, #14G$559,000

Related Listings

Tags:

Related Articles

For the Love of Loggias: Rare New York City listings with private outdoor rooms

Sublet or pay up? How homeowners could avoid the 2nd-home tax + Luxury listings for rent in condo/co-op buildings

25 NYC residential buildings with acclaimed in-house restaurants as Polo Bar plans move to 625 Madison

Price Cuts: Four-bed at The Dakota slashed by $3.8M; Majestic 30-foot-wide Brooklyn Heights house trimmed by $500K

In honor of Bastille Day, see NYC&#039;s grandest Beaux-Arts and French Renaissance-style buildings

Top 10 new development condos with common roof decks for grilling and lounging

NYC homes with bay windows to let the sun shine in

Taking game night to the next level: 15 NYC condos with elevated game rooms and billiards tables

Search

Market Data

Market Insight

CityRealty

My Account

-8.9% | -$1,250,000

19 Cranberry Street, #TH
$12,750,000

-3.6% | -$249,999

243 East 61st Street, #TH
$6,750,000

-5.2% | -$54,000

Noble LIC, #2A
$985,000

-6.9% | -$2,000,000

1110 Park Avenue, #PHTRIPLEX
$27,000,000

-5.1% | -$755,000

65 Bedford Street, #TH
$13,995,000

-7.9% | -$750,000

251 East 61st Street, #TH
$8,750,000

-16.1% | -$955,000

350 West 71st Street, #PHA
$4,995,000

-32% | -$1,550,000

77 Greenwich Street, #39-C
$3,300,000

-8.9% | -$250,000

The Wellesley, #5B
$2,550,000

-10% | -$250,000

Sutton Hall, #14B
$2,250,000

-7.8% | -$175,000

359 13th Street, #2
$2,075,000

-7.2% | -$155,000

The Alwyn Court, #11A
$1,995,000

-15.1% | -$355,000

The Endicott, #714
$1,995,000

-16.7% | -$350,000

50 West 127th Street, #7B
$1,750,000

-10.7% | -$170,000

100 United Nations Plaza, #7G
$1,425,000

-11.1% | -$150,001

2 Sutton Place South, #7F
$1,199,999

-8.8% | -$96,000

Coda Condominium, #11A
$999,000

-43.8% | -$741,000

459 West 18th Street, #1
$949,000

-10.1% | -$80,000

227 West 11th Street, #43
$715,000

-6.7% | -$40,000

Southgate, #14G
$559,000

In honor of Bastille Day, see NYC's grandest Beaux-Arts and French Renaissance-style buildings