Mill Rock Plaza, #22E (Corcoran)
It’s no secret that buying into the New York City market is more difficult than buying into most housing markets in North America. While cost is an obvious obstacle, what many aspiring owners don’t realize is that the actual cost of purchasing a unit is only the first barrier to ownership. High closing cost, higher-than-average co-op and condo fees (sometimes asked for in Escrow before closing), down payments exceeding the standard 15 to 20% threshold, and in co-ops, myriad arbitrary guidelines designed to keep desirable tenants in and undesirable tenants out all make the process of purchasing a first home more costly and stressful than in most other cities. Fortunately, a combination of strategy and good fortune can help first-time buyers dodge at least some of these obstacles.
In this article:
Troubleshooting the High Cost of Housing
According to CityRealty data, for the third quarter of 2023 the average sales price paid for a condo in Manhattan was $2.74 million ($1,761/ft2) and the median price of a co-op was $1.32M. With the exception of the Bay Area, where prices occasionally exceed those in New York City, the city generally faces little competition when it comes to high housing costs. While this does make it a difficult market for first-time buyers, there are at least a few ways to troubleshoot the cost and hassle of purchasing your first unit.
The most obvious strategy is to look for a condo unit in a yet-to-be-gentrified or up-and-coming neighborhood (e.g., Prospect Lefferts Gardens, Brooklyn or Sunnyside, Queens). Neither neighborhood is Soho, but remember—Soho itself was once considered an undesirable neighborhood and the same held true for the entire East Village and Lower East Side. Condo units generally have much fewer approval obstacles to face compared to compass and typically require a smaller downpayment. Bear in mind that any equity you sink into a unit in a gentrifying unit can usually be fully recovered if you decide to move, so at the very least, it is far more strategic than renting and may prove to be a great investment if you hold long enough to see the neighborhood undergo a major shift in value.
Any equity you sink into a unit in an up-and-coming neighborhood can usually be fully recovered if you decide to move.
Another potential strategy—if you qualify based on income and household size—is to consider purchasing an HDFC unit. In some instances, these units can provide an opportunity to buy in Manhattan or a highly active real estate market in Brooklyn at prices that are well below market value. If you do purchase an HDFC unit, however, your return on investment over time will be considerably lower, so in general, this solution is only recommended if you are looking to purchase with the intent of staying put over time. Read more about HDFC purchases here.
While there is no question that younger buyers do face especially steep challenges, it is possible for buyers under 30 and even under 25 to purchase units in New York City. Back in 2013, Polly Mosendz—at the time, she was 22-year-old and a recent New School graduate—published an article in the New York Observer about her purchase of a Greenwich Village apartment. According to the article, Mosendz had managed to purchase an apartment for $250,000. While the article was presumably written to offer evidence to the city’s youngest potential buyers that it is possible to buy before one starts to gray around the edges, Mosendz’s story was unusual enough to attract considerable attention. (Gawker even published a follow-up article, alleging that Mosendz hadn’t really purchased the apartment but relied on huge family gifts and a co-signer). So, is it possible for the very young to buy in New York City?
Down payments, Closing Costs, and Other Surprises
In many U.S. cities, even after the 2008 recession, housing programs continued to help first-time buyers with affordable low-money-down mortgages. In New York City, however, co-ops and condos typically will not work with buyers who are relying on first-time housing program mortgages. Indeed, many co-ops, even affordable HFDC co-ops, expect buyers to bring more than 20% to the deal (sometimes 80% to 100%), so putting 3% to 5% down is simply not an option.
Beyond the high down payment typically needed to buy into the local market, potential buyers also need to be prepared for higher than average closing costs and may even be hit with other surprises. Some co-ops, for example, ask new buyers to put up to three years of building fees in escrow. Notably, when buildings ask buyers to pay their fees upfront, the money is sitting in an escrow account but not being used to cover current fees. Indeed, it is just there to ensure that co-op that they will not be left high and dry if the new tenant stops paying their co-op fees at any time. However, where there is a will, there is a way, and at least some New Yorkers are finding innovative ways to dodge the down payment and fee obstacles that so often come with most co-op and condo purchases.
A growing number of New Yorkers are teaming up with siblings and even friends to co-purchase entire homes.
While not everyone’s dream scenario, a growing number of New Yorkers are teaming up with siblings and even friends to co-purchase entire homes in developing neighborhoods where prices for a share of a brownstone can often be much lower than purchasing a co-op or condo unit. This strategy also means that new buyers need only negotiate with the seller and lender—not an entire co-op or condo board. While any home purchase will come with additional responsibilities down the line—if the roof caves in, it is your problem, not your co-op board’s problem—for first-time buyers, purchasing an entire home can be a much easier way to enter the city’s difficult housing market. As an added bonus you’ll likely end up with something few New Yorkers own—a backyard.
Challenges Facing Young Buyers
Most adults love highly motivated and independent young adults—that is, until they attempt to purchase a co-op or condo unit in their building. Despite the fact that some young people have the means to do so, potential owners under 25 and even potential owners under 30 face especially steep hurdles on the real estate market.
First, even if one has a large down payment (e.g., from a recent inheritance) since one’s credit rating is based in part on the age of one’s accounts, there is simply no way for someone under 30 to have a perfect credit score. This invariably leads to higher interest rates and puts one into a higher risk category, even if they have an outstanding but short credit history. Second, there is the even larger problem of persuading a co-op board that one is a potentially desirable tenant.
The younger you are when you go on the housing market, the more likely you are to be asked to put down more money upfront.
Would you like to tour any of these properties?
Just complete the info below.
Or call us at (212) 755-5544
The long and short of it is that the younger you are when you go on the housing market, the more likely you are to be asked to put down more money upfront and to offer more assurances that you won’t stop paying your fees down the line (e.g., to put one or more years of fees in an escrow account). After all, even if you can afford a high down payment and prove that you can cover the monthly mortgage payments and building fees, co-op boards will still have a legitimate reason to assume that your income may not be as stable as someone who has been working for decades.
So, what are very young buyers to do? It might not feel entirely dignified, but if you need a co-signer to purchase your first unit, simply bite the bullet. In the end, the equity you gain by buying not renting in your twenties will put you in an ideal position to purchase a second unit by the time you’re in your early to mid-thirties, which is when most people are only beginning to think about purchasing their first home.
So, what are very young buyers to do? It might not feel entirely dignified, but if you need a co-signer to purchase your first unit, simply bite the bullet. In the end, the equity you gain by buying not renting in your twenties will put you in an ideal position to purchase a second unit by the time you’re in your early to mid-thirties, which is when most people are only beginning to think about purchasing their first home.
Newly-Listed Starter Apartments
333 East 79th Street, #15T (Compass)
86 Horatio Street, #4D (Brown Harris Stevens Residential Sales LLC)
Woodstock Tower, #2310 (Compass)
The Gramercy House, #15M (Compass)
The Guardsman, #3B (Compass)
Mill Rock Plaza, #22E (Corcoran Group)
Riverview East, #3B (Douglas Elliman Real Estate)
The Sandstone, #4 (Compass)
Lucent33, #2B (Nest Seekers LLC)
The Rembrandt, #10E (OFFICIAL)
40 Broad Street Condominium, #15D
$888,000
Financial District | Condominium | 1 Bedroom, 1.5 Baths | 943 ft2
40 Broad Street Condominium, #15D (Compass)
Greenwich Club, #2206 (Compass)
Stella Tower, #12B (Compass)
14 Sutton Place South, #12G (Compass)
547 West 47th Street, #710 (Corcoran Sunshine Marketing Group)
Five27, #2B (Brown Harris Stevens Queens LLC)
The Cosmopolitan, #34A (Brown Harris Stevens Residential Sales LLC)
Turtle Bay Towers, #23U (City Connections Realty Inc)
Umbrella Factory, #1F (MNS)
425 Fifth Avenue, #28A (Corcoran Group)
Monogram, #12C (CORE Group Marketing LLC)
Would you like to tour any of these properties?
Just complete the info below.
Or call us at (212) 755-5544
Would you like to tour any of these properties?
Contributing Writer
Cait Etherington
Cait Etherington has over twenty years of experience working as a journalist and communications consultant. Her articles and reviews have been published in newspapers and magazines across the United States and internationally. An experienced financial writer, Cait is committed to exposing the human side of stories about contemporary business, banking and workplace relations. She also enjoys writing about trends, lifestyles and real estate in New York City where she lives with her family in a cozy apartment on the twentieth floor of a Manhattan high rise.
6sqft delivers the latest on real estate, architecture, and design, straight from New York City.
