Skip to Content
  • Apartments
  • Overview & Photos
  • Maps
  • Ratings & Insider Info
  • Floorplans
  • Sales Data & Comps
  • Similar Buildings
  • All Units
1158 Fifth Avenue
Last updated on Feb 3, 2026

1158 Fifth Avenue

1158 Fifth Avenue is a landmarked prewar building completed in 1924, designed in French Renaissance-style with a limestone base and tan brick exterior. Located in Carnegie Hill near Central Park, it offers amenities like a fitness center and full-time staff, with financing allowed up to 40% and pets permitted. Currently, 2 apartments are for sale.

1158 Fifth Avenue Location Map
Unit #
Beds
Baths
Size
Price / Ft2
Price
Listed on
Days on Market
Unit #
Beds
Baths
Size
Closing Price
Price / Ft2
Asking Price
Sold on
View Full Sales History

Overview of 1158 Fifth Avenue

1158 Fifth Avenue is a landmarked prewar building completed in 1924 and incorporated in 1945. Designed by C. Howard Crane and Kenneth Franzheim in the French Renaissance-style, the building sits atop a 3-story limestone base and is clad in tan brick with wrought iron and limestone detailing. Its beautiful lobby features vaulted ceilings and ornate original details. Residents are serviced by a full-time staff of doormen and concierges as well as a live-in resident manager, and amenities include a fitness center, private storage, bicycle storage and central laundry.

Located in prime Carnegie Hill and along Central Park, it is surrounded by the finest of the city's museums, a rich host of luxury and boutique shopping and dining and Manhattan's most preeminent schools. Financing is allowed up to 40%, and pets are permitted.

Doorman
Full Time
Type
Co-op
Year Built
1924
Apartments
Floors
15
Pets: Allowed
Neighborhood
Min Down
60%

Amenities

  • Concierge
  • FT Doorman
  • Pre War
  • Elevator
  • Fitness Center
  • Laundry Room
  • Bike Room
  • Landmarked
{ "key" : "AIzaSyDquABdSLhathmwfnoTcYwA1BY6coZZyZk", "lat": 40.78824, "lng": -73.95504, "marker": { "icon": "https://img3.cityrealty.com/neo/i/w/amenities/base.png" } }

  1. 6
at Lexington Ave 0.27 miles

Pros & Cons

  • Handsome building
  • Doorman
  • Attractive sidewalk landscaping
  • Close to Mt. Sinai Hospital
  • Close to many museums
  • Impressive Central Park views
  • Close to many private schools
  • Close to Subway
  • No sundeck
  • Westbound 96th Street cross-town bus stops across the street on 97th Street
  • No garage
  • No balconies
  • No health club

CityRealty Rating

26
/44
Architecture
+
25
/36
Location
+
21
/39
Features
+
10
Editor’s Points
=
82
CITYREALTY
RATING
  • How is the CityRealty Rating calculated?

    Architecture
    • 30+ remarkable
    • 20-29 distinguished
    • 11-19 average
    • < 11 below average
    Location
    • 27+ remarkable
    • 18-26 distinguished
    • 9-17 average
    • < 9 below average
    Features
    • 22+ remarkable
    • 16-21 distinguished
    • 9-15 average
    • < 9 below average

Sales History

Price/Room (Est)

Why are we displaying the estimated price per room?

For some co-ops, instead of price per square foot, we use an estimate of the number of rooms for each sold apartment to chart price changes over time. This is because many co-op listings do not include square footage information, and this makes it challenging to calculate accurate square-foot averages.

By displaying the price per estimated room count, we are able to provide a more reliable and consistent metric for comparing sales in the building. While we hope that this gives you a clearer sense of price trends in the building, all data should be independently verified. All data provided are only estimates and should not be used to make any purchase or sale decision.

Price/Ft2 (Est)
View Full Closing History

Sales Summary

Show:

Sales History by Apartment Size

View Full Closing History
Show:

Pricing Comparison of Similar Buildings

View Detailed Comparison
between Gold Street & Flatbush Avenue Extension
Downtown Brooklyn
Tax-abated condos with panoramic NYC views Studio - 3-bed condos starting from $1M Immediate Occupancy | Call to schedule your tour
Learn More
Brooklyn Point - Skyline View Brooklyn Point - Rooftop Pool View Brooklyn Point - Master Bedroom Brooklyn Point - Living Room Brooklyn Point - Wine Room