Skip to Content
CityRealty Logo
Future New York

NYC's top 10 most expensive neighborhoods; See their trophy apartments and most attainable listings inside

15 Central Park West, PH41 via Douglas Elliman 15 Central Park West, PH41 via Douglas Elliman
Between the COVID-19 pandemic, the economic fallout of the efforts to contain it, and historically low interest rates, it is hard to say what effect this will have on the New York real estate market. On the one hand, rumblings of a recession and the cancellation of traditional showings may deter some from making big-ticket purchases. At the same time, virtual and video showings are getting more elaborate and personalized every day, some buyers see New York real estate as a safer investment than some banks, and still others are eager to lock in said interest rates.

In this article:

Whitney Condos, 33 East 74th Street
Whitney Condos, 33 East 74th Street Park/Fifth Ave. to 79th St.
One Central Park, 25 Columbus Circle
One Central Park, 25 Columbus Circle Central Park West
53 West 53rd Street
53 West 53rd Street Midtown West
165 Charles Street
165 Charles Street West Village
One Manhattan Square, 252 South Street
One Manhattan Square, 252 South Street Lower East Side
According to CityRealty's Q1 Residential Market Report, Manhattan sales prices have dipped 10% when compared year-over-year to Q1 2019. While we can't say what the future holds, we can say with certainty which neighborhoods were the most expensive of the first quarter of 2020. With the quarter ending at the end of March, the full effects of the citywide shut down beginning on March 15 are not apparent. All figures reflect condo sales closed in the first quarter of 2020, and the list is ranked by price per square foot (PPSF). The PPSF, total number of condo transactions in the quarter, and the average condo price figures are compared year-over-year to the first quarter of 2019.

The stats below are coupled with each neighborhood's premier condo listing along with its most affordable condo listing. We wanted to show that there are attainable and attractive homes to be found even in the most expensive parts of New York City. The listings are paired with local scenes we look forward to enjoying again.

1) Gold Coast, Upper East Side | Avg. Condo PPSF: $3,058 (-32%)

5 sales (-58%) | Avg. Price: $13M (-20%)

Whitney Condos, 33 East 74th Street, TH Whitney Condos, 33 East 74th Street, TH (via Douglas Elliman)

32-East-76th-Street-01 Gallery Apartments via The Corcoran Group

2) Nolita/Little Italy | Avg. condo PPSF: $2,460 (+50%)

21 sales (+163%) | Avg. price: $3.1M (-5%)

(CityRealty)
Puck Penthouses The Modlin Group

↓ 200 Bowery, #2D – $1.05M

Condo | 2 Bed, 1 Bath
200-Bowery-01 200 Bowery via Compass

3) West Village | Avg. condo PPSF: $2,418 (-2%)

17 sales (+42%) | Avg. price: $5.7M (-1%)

165 Charles Street, #TRIPLEX (Brown Harris Stevens)

3-Weehawken-Street-01 3 Weehawken Street via Compass

4) Greenwich Village | Avg. condo PPSF: $2,402 (+14%)

20 sales (+18%) | Avg. price: $4.4M (+42%)

37 East 12th Street, #PH (Compass)

1-Morton-Square-01 Morton Square via Compass

5) Lincoln Center | Avg. condo PPSF: $2,320 (+20%)

45 sales (+181%) | Avg. price: $2.5M (+41%)

The Grand Millennium, 1965 Broadway, #PH2B The Grand Millennium, #PH2B (Corcoran)

10-West-End-Avenue-01 10 West End Avenue via The Corcoran Group

6) Noho | Avg. condo PPSF: $2,218 (+61%)

3 sales (-40%) | Avg. price: $5.3M (+103%)

The Carl Fischer Building, 62 Cooper Square, #PH52 The Carl Fischer Building, #PH52 (Douglas Elliman)
Would you like to tour any of these properties?
Just complete the info below.
  1. Select which properties are of interest to you:

Or call us at (212) 755-5544

14-East-4th-Street-01 The Silk Building via Compass

7) Midtown West | Avg. condo ppsf: $2,203 (-7%)

124 sales (-16%) | Avg. price: $4.3M (-18%)

53W53, 53 West 53rd Street, #PH76 (Corcoran)

393-West-49th-Street-01 Worldwide Plaza via The Corcoran Group

8) Soho | Avg. condo ppsf: $1,935 (-4%)

28 sales (+22%) | Avg. price: $2.6M (-49%)


77-Charlton-Street-01 77 Charlton Street via Toll Brothers Real Estate

9) Riverside Drive/West End Avenue | Avg. condo PPSF: $1,933 (+7%)

60 sales (+15%) | Avg. price: $3M (-8%)

One West End, #29B Cantor-Pecorella One West End, #29B Cantor-Pecorella

200-Riverside-Boulevard-01 200 Riverside Boulevard via Nest Seekers

10) Flatiron/Union Square | Avg. condo ppsf: $1,921 (-3%)

41 sales (-13%) | Avg. price: $3.6M (+33%)

240 Park Avenue South, #Penthouse 240 Park Avenue South, #Penthouse (Sotheby's)

1-Irving-Place-01 Zeckendorf Towers via Compass

11) Central Park West | Avg. condo PPSF: $1,894 (-13%)

30 sales (+20%) | Avg. price: $3.3M (-16%)

Time Warner Center, 25 Columbus Circle, #PH80 Time Warner Center, #PH80 (Corcoran)

300-West-110th-Street-01 Towers on the Park I via Keller Williams

12) Lower East Side | Avg. condo ppsf: $1,807 (-4%)

35 sales (-30%) | Avg. price: $1.6M (-9%)

One Manhattan Square One Manhattan Square (Extell Development Company)

101-Allen-Street-01 101 Allen Street via Compass

Would you like to tour any of these properties?
Just complete the info below.
  1. Select which properties are of interest to you:

Or call us at (212) 755-5544
Would you like to tour any of these properties?

Related Articles

Get To Know

Swim with a View: 30 Manhattan buildings with high-floor swimming pools and fitness centers

Saturday, June 20, 2026
Coney Island

Knicks in Five: 35 NYC condo and rental buildings with basketball courts

Thursday, June 18, 2026
Riverside Dr./West End Ave.

Three Waterline Square launches lottery for UWS apartments priced from $782/month

Wednesday, June 10, 2026
Future New York

Making an Entrance: Top NYC Buildings with Porte-Cocheres and Dramatic Driveways

Wednesday, June 3, 2026
Future New York

Top 15 fitness centers in NYC condos as Radiant hits 60% sold and readies for move-ins

Friday, May 29, 2026
Future New York

When, why, and how to hire a home inspector + Great new listings with outdoor space from $595K

Saturday, May 9, 2026
Future New York

Stay Flexible! 10 NYC condo buildings with dedicated Pilates rooms among wellness amenities

Friday, May 8, 2026
Future New York

Price Cuts: Bill Cosby's UES townhouse reduced by 14%; Palatial 5-bed at The Dakota now $5M off

Thursday, May 7, 2026